In Response to "Nature Society is Making Baseless Claim, Says Botanist",
18 March 1999
Further to the March 18,
issue of the STAR, we would like to reiterate here that MNS did not make
the “baseless” claim that the sampling size was small, and non-timber trees
were under-represented. The claim was made by Dr. S. Appanah of
FRIM, and MNS and WWF supports this. The MNS would also like to clarify
that there are many species of the ‘berembang’, and the species that we
are concerned with are the Sonneratia caseolaris, which, though capable
of tolerating high salinity levels, prefers freshwater habitats. The Sonneratia
caseolaris seems to be highly preferred by fireflies for their blinking
displays, and possibly, for some of their food needs.
The MNS had made a study, "Strategies
for Conservation and Tourism Development at Sungai Selangor Riparian Forest,
1997". It was observed that the Sonneratia caseolaris grows well in tidal
zones and are dominant where the salinity is between 3-10 parts of a thousand.
In Kuala Selangor, the plants form a thin belt of about 18 kilometers starting
before Kampong Sepakat and extending beyond Tanjong Pasir. The trees are
concentrated along 2 points along the river. One is about one kilometer
to the west of Kampong Kuantan towards Kuala Selangor and the other is
about a half a kilometer to the east towards Batang Berjuntai.' It is obvious
that they prefer a more freshwater condition, and are only salt tolerant
to a certain extant. There is however a last stand of around 10 trees near
the bridge on the way to Pasir Penampang village. However, these trees
are not very healthy.
MNS hopes that this will clarify
the whole situation as it relates to the berembang trees and the fireflies.
Dato' Dr Salleh Mohd Nor
(Letters to the Editor)
Back to 1999 May Newsletter index
[
Back to MNS Perak Home ]
Created on 26th April 1999.