Temple and Synagogue: seperate institutions
The Holy Temple in Jerusalem was the Beth haMiqdash. There
was to be only one temple in the Land, the objective of all
sacrifices and pilgrimages.
During late 2nd Temple days, local gatherings were held
at a beth k*nesseth. It doubled as a beth t*fillah for
communal prayer and a beth midrash for studies. The
Greek word synagogue somehow became the vernacular
for the beth k*nesseth. When the 2nd Temple was
destroyed and 4th century plans to build a new Temple
died with the Roman emperor Julian, only the synagogue survived as an
institute for Jewish worship.
Until relatively recent times there were only three
other temples. One in Upper Egypt in use between the
1st and 2nd Jerusalem Temple. One rival temple in
Jordan. One that the Mishnah speaks in some length
about was in Egypt's delta. Being a miqdash it was
functionally (not architecturally) modeled after
Jerusalem's Beth Miqdash. This temple operated for
about 250 years, from the Hasmonean period until just
after the siege at Masada.
From the historical perspective, synagogues were never
spoken of as temples nor served the Mosaic Code
functions of a temple. The Temple and the synagogue
operated simultaneously for roughly two centuries.
One for Moses' literal sacrifice and the other for
Hosea's verbal sacrifice.
Calling the beth k*nessth a temple is an innocuous
enough designation. Used mainly by liberal leaning
congegrations the term is also, but very infrequently,
used by traditional congregations as well, like the
Sephardic Temple in Cedarhurst.
For certain, no one thinks of these congregational
buildings as the Beth Miqdash but rather as a beth
t*fillah.
SR' Yafeu ibn Taom
© 2000 RCAJA® for the Anusim List. © 2003 RCAJA® All rights reserved world wide.
KEYWORDS House of the Holy House of God