1999: St. Louis Cardinals defeat Anaheim Angels (4-3)
1999: New York (N) Mets defeat Texas Rangers (4-1)
1999: Baltimore Orioles defeat St. Louis Cardinals (4-3)
2000: Philadelphia Phillies defeat Boston Red Sox (4-0)

No awards given for this catagory.

1B Harold Baines (DET) eligible 2005
3B Tony Fernandez (STL) eligible 2005
3B Wade Boggs (KC) eligible 2005
RF Tony Gwynn (TOR) eligible 2005
 P Jesse Orosco (ANA) eligible 2005
 P Mike Morgan (HOU) eligible 2005
 P Mark Langston (PHI) eligible 2005
 C Jim Leyritz (TEX) eligible 2005
 C Jeff Reed (NYM) eligible 2006
3B Cal Ripken Jr. (PHI) eligible 2006
1B Andres Galarraga (SEA) eligible 2006
 P Dan Plesac (MON) eligible 2006
 P Randy Myers (CHN) eligible 2006
 P Jamie Moyer (OAK) eligible 2006
LF B.J. Surhoff (TEX) eligible 2006

1999: Alex Rodriguez (SS), MIN (.312 AVG, 41 HR, 106 RBI)
2000: Jeffery Hammonds (RF), BOS (.311 AVG, 40 HR, 100 RBI)

1999: Nomar Garciaparra (SS), STL (.335 AVG, 47 HR, 143 RBI)
2000: Larry Walker (RF), SF (.388 AVG, 72 HR, 173 RBI)

1999: Pedro J. Martinez, (P, BOS) (22-4, 1.50 ERA, 302 K's)
2000: Pedro J. Martinez, (P, BOS) (29-2, 1.26 ERA, 319 K's)

1999: Kevin Brown, (P, SF) (20-6, 1.99 ERA, 199 K's)
2000: Brad Radke, (P, CIN) (20-7, 2.23 ERA, 211 K's)

1999: Marlon Anderson (2B), TOR (.269 AVG, 13 HR, 61 RBI)
2000: Gabe Kapler (RF), TB (.250 AVG, 23 HR, 65 RBI)

1999: Chris Singleton (CF), CIN (.280 AVG, 19 HR, 49 RBI)
2000: Alex Rios (3B), MON (.279 AVG, 10 HR, 60 RBI)

No awards given for this catagory.

2000: Larry Walker (RF, SF) (.388, 72, 173)