| Frontier Champion | Defended | Captured On | Defeated | Captured At | Title Reign |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Berserker Dave | once | 10/30/98 | Vacant | #4: Total Conq. PPV | 27 Days |
| J. Rabesque | 3 times | 11/25/98 | Berserker Dave | #5: Milwaukee BG | 6 Months 13 Days |
| Wayne Roberts | once | 7/10/99 | Vacant | #20: San Antonio BG | 1 Month |
| Abel Wicks | twice | 8/29/99 | Vacant | #22: Charlotte BG | 1 Month 26 Days |
| J. Rabesque | twice | 10/23/99 | Abel Wicks | #25: Wres. Bowl-I PPV | 2 Months |
| Ricky Kabe | never | 11/29/99 | J. Rabesque | #28: Philly HC | 29 days |
| Vacant | n/a | 12/27/99 | Title Held Up | #29: Baltimore BG | n/a |
| Jean Rabesque | once | 1/16/00 | Title Held Up | #31: Pittsburgh BG | 1 Month 13 Days |
| Stone Wolf | 3 times | 2/27/00 | Jean Rabesque | #34: Des Moines BG | 2 Months 2 days |
| Anarky | once | 4/28/00 | Stone Wolf | #38: Salt Lake City BG | 27 days |
| Vacant | N/A | 5/24/00 | Vacated | #40: PPV: WI Y2K | Vacant |
| The Jobber | once | 7/12/00 | Maxwell Houz | #43: Dodger Stadium BG | Current Champ |
