| Tag Team Champs | Defended | Captured On | Defeated | Captured At | Title Reign |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SaD | 4 times | 10/30/98 | Vacant | #4: Total Conq. PPV | 4 Months 18 Days |
| BoP | once | 3/16/99 | SaD | #14: Atlanta BG | 1 Month 27 Days |
| Mercenaries | once | 5/11/99 | BoP | #17: Div. & Conq. PPV | 26 Days |
| Cat Pack | twice | 6/5/99 | Mercenaries | #18: Houston BG | 2 Months 5 Days |
| New Breed | 9 times | 8/8/99 | Cat Pack | #21: Miami BG | 9 Months 18 Days | Cat Pack | 3 times | 5/24/00 | New Breed | #40: PPV: WI Y2K | Current Champs |
