| X-Treme Champion | Defended | Captured On | Defeated | Captured At | Title Reign |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Asylum | 6 times | 11/13/99 | Vacant | #27: DC BG | 5 Months 18 Days |
| Vacant | N/A | 4/28/00 | Vacated | #38: Salt Lake City BG | N/A |
| Suicide King | once | 5/24/00 | JD Badluck | #40: PPV: WI Y2K | 1 Month, 20 days |
| Nemesis | never | 7/12/00 | Suicide King | #43: Dodger Stadium BG | Current Champ |
