"The finest translation of Homer ever made into
the English language."
-William Arrowsmith, Hudson Review
"Certainly the best modern verse
translation."
-Gilbert Highet
"The best modern Iliad is that of
Richard Lattimore . . . Lattimore is as much a scholar as a poet."
-Hugh Lloyd-Jones
Homers Iliad originated at the beginnings of Western
civilization. Its power is so timeless that it has been read continuously for more than
2500 years. Yet its origin lies shrouded in mystery, tangled in mythology, religion, and
ancient tribal history. Aside from these elements, the real excitement of the Iliad lies
in its brilliant poetry, which is sustained for more than 15,000 lines, bringing an age of
heroes and their exploits to life with clarity, complexity, and depth of feeling.
Homer has been known since classical Greek times as the author of the Odyssey and the
Iliad- and that is about all that can be said for certain about him. The ancients regarded
him as practically a god, equal to the muses (who were the divine inspiration for all
arts). Facts about Homer the man have long been the subject of hot debate among scholars.
Perhaps Homer also wrote a group of long poems, still called the Homeric Hymns. Perhaps
Homer didnt actually write the two great epic poems but merely pieced together small
sections written by many different poets over centuries. Perhaps there was no Homer at
all, and the poems were a kind of oral history, written and recited by numerous poets and
much later collected into the books we now know. Each of these theories has been offered
as true, and each remains unproven.
What is certain is that the ancient Greek scholars and commentators were convinced that
Homer was real and lived in the 9th or 8th century B.C. Modern scholars generally agree
that the Iliad was composed around 725 B.C. (the earli-
est written versions we have are hundreds of years later than that, so theres plenty
of room for conjecture). But though we dont have the earliest texts, the ancient
Greeks did, and Homer was written about, discussed, and analyzed throughout the classical
Greek period.
One of the key controversies among Homeric critics is whether Homer composed his poems
orally or whether he actually wrote them down. We do know that Homers poems were
recited in later days, at festivals and ceremonial occasions, by professional singers
called rhapsodes, who beat out the measure with rhythm staffs. (There is a similar
poet/singer in the Odyssey who sings a poem about the Trojan War. He is an old man, and
blind; that may be the source behind the legend that Homer himself was blind.) Whether or
not Homer actually wrote down his poems, it now seems certain that the Iliad and the
Odyssey are part of an ancient literary tradition of oral composition. The stories on
which they are based had probably been sung aloud for hundreds of years, and recited and
memorized by one generation of poets after another before Homer took them in hand. After
all, in Homers time, writing was used mostly for inventories and business
transactions. Recitation was the accepted means of relating myth and history.
The Iliad was part of a group of ancient poems known as the Epic Cycle, which dealt with
the history of the Trojan War and the events surrounding it.
Homer probably had at his fingertips most of these stories and characters, readymade. His
genius lay in choosing to focus on the story of Achilleus and in bring-
ing a tragic depth to the story of the battle for Troy. Homer was writing about events
that took place four or five hundred years before his own time, events already enlarged by
the glamor of the past. However tall Achilleus and Hektor actually were, by Homers
time their size was legendary, rather like that of comic book superheroes. For the Greeks,
these heroes represented the ideals on which their civilization was based. At the same
time, they symbolized elements of the human psyche, with its yearning for nobility and
honor.
The world of the Iliad is based on history but grows into metaphor: we must look beneath
the facts to its deeper meaning. Archaeologists have indeed discovered the remains of a
supposed Troy on the coast of Turkey and the majestic ruins of palaces and tombs in
Mykenai on the plains of Greece. Through the lines of the Iliad, however, the Greeks and
Trojans still live for us, echoing in the human imagination.
Richard Lattimore was professor
emeritus of Greek at Bryn Mawr College at the time of his death in 1984. He was coeditor
(with David Grene) of The Complete Greek
Tragedies, translator of Greek Lyrics, and author
of Poems from Three
Decades, all published by the University of Chicago Press. |