A comparision of art

"Bad Day for Troop A" (JW 8-02, page 2/6)


 
Left: Rough pencil by Carl Barks (1970)
Right: Final artwork by Tony Strobl (1970)
Below: Final artwork by Daan Jippes (1991)


Note: This comparision is not meant to tell which artist is 'the best'. Its intention is to show an original rough idea and how it was interpreted by two different artists. Carl Barks' and Tony Strobl's art is taken from set 6 of "The Carl Barks Library" (page 174), Daan Jippes' art is taken from Dutch comic book album "Beste Verhalen van Donald Duck" 86.

HOME