FC Navigation ConsoleFortuneCity ad

Pirate Pete's Page of MOD Reviews

Page 3 of 6

Last updated: 25 Jul 00 at 11:13 AM

 

Pirate Pete

Welcome to Pirate Pete's Mod Reviews Page! You'll find here a collection of my reviews of mods which were either emailed to me or I have picked up in my travels on the Web.

If you are interested in how I began reviewing mods and the methodology I use to review them, see "Notes about the reviews".

Reviews are grouped in pages of 20 reviews per page. Use this index page to select a review to read (reviews are sorted chronologically); clicking on the song title will take you to the review. Alternatively, you can use the navigational links ("next", "previous", "first", "last") to view the reviews a whole page at a time.

If you want to listen to the song for yourself, click on the song URL (beneath the song title) to download it [Note: some songs which I have on my local drive do not have links -- I will email you one or more of these songs if you request it...but only ONE song per day!]

Reviews 41 to 50

Song #41

"Agent-77"

File size (uncompressed)

1440 Kb

URL:

http://www.neosoft.com/~clones/agent77-.zip

Date reviewed:

23 Aug 1998
Style:Rock
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):6:22
Artist(s):Chris and the Clones ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:6.50 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 7  Middle: 6  Closing: 7  Headphone: 6  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes, especially if you're a secret agent fan.
Review:Since I'm a secret agent fan from way back (I was weaned on James Bond, Nick Carter, Maxwell Smart, and Lancelot Link, Superchimp), I was eager to review this song. And I wasn't disappointed. From the heavy metal guitars to the mysterious-sounding chord progressions, "Agent 77" maintained the targeted ambience throughout, placing the listener in a mood for a litte spying and larceny (for God and country, of course). There were a few parts that irritated my ears at max volume--the high synth leads were perhaps a bit *too* rambunctious, and the percussion could have used another instrument (a stronger bass drum, perhaps?) But all in all, the artist (ah, what the heck, we all know him by now--take a bow, Chris) did an excellent job with this song.

(And finally!! Pete got his name in some sample greetz! Ya-haaaaaaaarrrrr, I be one happy buccaneer! ;-)

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #42

"Speedy Recovery"

File size (uncompressed)

523 Kb

URL:

http://www.acid.demon.nl/tracks/mw_speed.zip

Date reviewed:

26 Aug 1998
Style:Rave/Acid/Demo
Format:ProTracker compatible (.mod)
Time (via ModPlug):10:47
Artist(s):wOOd of Acid Demons ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:6.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 6  Middle: 6  Closing: 6  Headphone: 6  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes.
Review:Much work went into this musical feast in 7 movements (the artist states he did it all in one monstrous 11 hour tracking marathon). I feel obligated to spend a little time analyzing the mod...but this mod is beyond analysis, it must be EXPERIENCED...if you're going to do this song justice, listen to it with headphones with Bass Boost enabled!

Notice I've subtitled the movements based on the images they conjure up in my head...

1st movement: 0:00 - "Acid Train". You start the song thinking, "Ah, Amiga demo, phooey! That stuff is outdated..." Then you pop on the old headphones and decide to give this song a go...in your mind you see a Acid band boarding a train bound for the CoolSound Demofest at Helsinki, Finland. You hop on board yourself to hear more; your feet can't help but boogey to the beat as the train pulls out of the station...

2nd movement: 1:46 - "Acid Jive Talkin'" - Making your way to the restaurant car for a wine cooler, you stop in the entertainment lounge to catch the show. Scatman Carrothers is regaling the audience with his hip hilarious "sca-dat-n-dit-dee-bop-de-bo" vocalizations ...

3rd movement: 3:13 - "Acid Train Redux" - As the train pulls into the next stop, you hear some joker talking about "Speedy Gonzalez". You holler "Where?", but realize you're too slow on the uptake...

4th movement: 4:18 - "Acid Tension" The train pulls out again, the slow clickety-clack of the wheels on the track lulling you into false sense of security. Little do you realize Der Kommisar is waiting for you at the end of the line...do you have the correct papers!?

5th movement: 5:15 - "Mad Gypsy Dancers" - As you pass the beautiful Hungarian countryside (on your way to Finlandia, mind you), you spot a group of gypsy dancers, madly dancing in the moonlight...

6th movement: 6:57 - "Begin the Beguine" - Back in the lounge car, you struggle in vain to tempt the Contessa de Montfort onto the dance floor for a little fancy footwork a la Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers. Unfortunately, you have two left feet and she knows it...

7th movement: 8:35 - "Last Tango in Helsinki" - two hours from your destination, you finally break down the Contessa's fears when the band begins an "acid tango". You prove to her and to yourself (and everyone else on the train) that you don't have two left feet. Of course, you're no Fred Astaire, but then again, the Contessa's no Ginger Rogers. either. The two of you dance the remaining time away, enrapt in each other's embrace until the conductor comes in and shoo's you off the train.

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #43

"'95 House-megamix"

File size (uncompressed)

684 Kb

URL:

ftp://ftp.wustl.edu/aminet/systems/amiga/aminet/mods/house/95HouseMegamix.lha

Date reviewed:

27 Aug 1998
Style:House
Format:ProTracker compatible (.mod)
Time (via ModPlug):12:24
Artist(s):Ravebusters ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:8.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 8  Middle: 8  Closing: 8  Headphone: 8  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Definitely.
Review:This mix rocks!!

Okay, I hear you complaining, "Why did this get such a high rating? It's the same stuff over and over and over and over..." Yes, but that is exactly what a modern dance track is designed to do...this song would fit in perfectly when played at any dance club throughout the world. When I listen to the song, I picture a club in Newport Beach, California by the name of "Bobby McGhee's." -- they didn't have house when I was there last (oh so many years ago), but they had disco, which is mighty close. I had many fond memories of that club -- Kahlua and Milk was my poison back when I was a dancin' fool -- arrr, I'd better stop reminiscing here, milady has reached for her rollin' pin!

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #44

"House-T-01"

File size (uncompressed)

541 Kb

URL:

ftp://ftp.wustl.edu/aminet/systems/amiga/aminet/mods/house/1-house.lha

Date reviewed:

28 Aug 1998
Style:House
Format:ProTracker compatible (.mod)
Time (via ModPlug):3:53
Artist(s):Holger K ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:6.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 6  Middle: 6  Closing: 6  Headphone: 6  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes
Review:Good dance track; solid rhythm section, lots of synths and good use of a minimal number of vocal samples. Sounds a little dry and unbalanced stereo-wise without ModPlug's Surround/Bass Expansion/Reverb effects, but considering that this is an Amiga 4-channel mod, over all this is a finely done production. Nice job, Holger!
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #45

"Acid House"

URL:

ftp://ftp.wustl.edu/aminet/systems/amiga/aminet/mods/house/2-house.lha

Date reviewed:

29 Aug 1998
Style:House
Format:ProTracker compatible (.mod)
Time (via ModPlug):3:52
Artist(s):Holger K ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:5.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 5  Middle: 5  Closing: 5  Headphone: 5  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes
Review:There's one spot where the song doesn't live up to the dance track "standard"; at 1:29 there is a 15-20 sec stretch of vocalizations ("What was it like growin' uptown?") with no backbeat (kind of hard to dance to). But the song is saved from banality by some cool voice samples later on.
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #46

"Dance (Club Mix)"

File size (uncompressed)

99 Kb

URL:

ftp://ftp.wustl.edu/aminet/systems/amiga/aminet/mods/house/DanceclubMix.lha

Date reviewed:

30 Aug 1998
Style:House/Disco
Format:ProTracker compatible (.mod)
Time (via ModPlug):4:13
Artist(s):Dutch of Superlative Systems
Pete's overall rating:5.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 5  Middle: 5  Closing: 5  Headphone: 5  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes
Review:More disco than house, the song still tittilates my ears (remember, old Pete is a disco/techno pirate!). The Latin-flavored rhythm section is exactly the kind of beat you would've found in the big discotheques back in the late 70's. One of my favorite night spots, Bobby McGhee's of Newport Beach, CA, would have had this song blasting on remix for thirty of forty minutes. While I love the beat, the overall rating of 5 is based on comparisons with other songs in the same genre.
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #47

"Days of Glory"

File size (uncompressed)

891 Kb

URL:

http://members.xoom.com/trobeweb/zip/tro-days.zip

Date reviewed:

31 Aug 1998
Style:House
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):3:44
Artist(s):Trobe of BoumBoumClap Records ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:6.75 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 7  Middle: 7  Closing: 7  Headphone: 6  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes.
Review:An excellent house mod! A haunting pan-flute melody driven by a light-to-heavy techno/house beat. The song makes me think of a Japanese ex-soldier, now in his 80's, reminiscing about the days of glory of the land of the Rising Sun. I found the song to be a little left-heavy in my headphones, but other than that, I can't find anything to gripe about -- this is truly a beautiful song!
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #48

"Fur Swan (Bagdad Cafe)"

File size (uncompressed)

681 Kb

URL:

http://www.geocities.com/SunsetStrip/Stadium/7744/sounds/furswan.zip

Date reviewed:

02 Sep 1998
Style:Techno
Format:Impulse Tracker (.it)
Time (via ModPlug):4:27
Artist(s):Trib ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:3.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 3  Middle: 3  Closing: 3  Headphone: 3  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes.
Review:A bit one-dimensional in terms of musical depth, but the song does have its moments: the percussion track is well suited for the piece (bass drums could be a little quieter); the mysterious flute melody is strongly Arabic/Middle Eastern (hence the title, I suppose); the opening and closing voice samples are cool, although I'm not sure of their relevance to the song as a whole. For a beginning attempt (this is Trib's first MOD), this piece is excellent. Keep yer eye on this swabbie, maties. Old Pete looks forward to great things to come from him...
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #49

"Amateur"

URL:

http://www.neosoft.com/~clones/amateur.zip

Date reviewed:

03 Sep 1998
Style:Experimental
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):6:24
Artist(s):Chris and the Clones ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:1.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 1  Middle: 1  Closing: 1  Headphone: 1  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Not unless you're a masochist!
Review:Wow, did this song grate on my ears! Hate to say it, Chris, but if I'm not truthful then my reviews have no meaning even to myself. The opening made no sense, musically speaking. The extreme dissonance in parts was physically painful. There is no "song" per se, just a series of scratchy sound effects leading into a disharmonious synth organ portamento. I couldn't tell what language the lady in the voice sample is speaking, but the constant left-to-right pan of that sample (and others) threw me for a loop.

My apologies for the negative review, Chris. The reason for such a low rating is because I know you've done *much* better!

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #50

"Sonata01"

File size (uncompressed)

336 Kb

URL:

http://members.tripod.com/~chris_and_the_clones/sonata01.zip

Date reviewed:

04 Sep 1998
Style:Experimental
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):10:54
Artist(s):Chris and the Clones ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:3.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 3  Middle: 3  Closing: 3  Headphone: 3  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Hmmmmmm...yes, if only to witness Chris's technical skills.
Review:Although this piece displays the artist's excellent technical skills with a piano, the lack of a sustaining melody drove me to distraction. At times there were stretches of proto-melodies, but the artist quickly stomped them out (help stamp out consonance! ;-) ) with a series of lightning-quick dissonant chords and random-sounding arpeggios. Nothing wrong with a little dissonance, mind you, but if the *entire song* is based on dissonance...well, I don't rightly know what to say (arr, and that be somethin', Pete be out of words!). The last 3 minutes of the song did seem to attempt to begin a melody of sorts, but the tune rambled, never seeming to "find its center". I'd expect to hear this kind of music in a narrated children's story ("The Walrus & the Penguin", for example).
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Reviews 51 to 60

Song #51

"Techno Seasons"

File size (uncompressed)

354 Kb

URL:

http://www.s3m.com/music/preylude/techs_ii.zip

Date reviewed:

05 Sep 1998
Style:Symphonic Techno
Format:Impulse Tracker (.it)
Time (via ModPlug):4:10
Artist(s):Preylude of Reversed Logic ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:9.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 9  Middle: 9  Closing: 9  Headphone: 9  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes!
Review:This song is incredibly beautiful...it brought tears to my eyes! How can such a simple tune, derived from the works of the masters (and I mean the older masters--Bach, Beethoven, and Brahms--not the younger generation [yet, in the end, let's face it, a Master is a Master, no matter which musical "era" you're talking about]) elicit such an emotional response? I have no idea, nor do I care; I simply enjoy the experience and express my gratitude for being allowed to be a part of it (Whooooooooeeee! Pete's on a roll!) My hats off to you, Preylude, for this wonderful composition--O Canada!
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #52

"Don't Cry"

File size (uncompressed)

1554 Kb

URL:

http://www.fortunecity.com/tinpan/supergrass/400/dontcry.zip

Date reviewed:

07 Sep 1998
Style:Symphonic Techno
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):5:03
Artist(s):Lord Erman & Baron X of Badlam ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:7.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 7  Middle: 7  Closing: 7  Headphone: 7  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Most definitely.
Review:Okay, I can take a hint -- from now on, old Pete will pay closer attention to the technical details of the songs I review (you might say I'm in bootcamp for my reviews over at WMR), including (*gasp*) sample quality. Ack! I used to hate reviews of my stuff that trashed my compositions merely because of sample quality, not taking into consideration the content of the music itself; but after 51 reviews, I begin to see where the reviewers were coming from.

"Don't Cry" begins with some simple yet haunting A-minor / C-major piano riffs (E-C-E-B-E-G is the main tonic), bringing in an electic guitar (which sounds just a tad bit flat, BTW) at the end of the first pattern. I love the way Badlam uses two channels (four, actually, but the second two channels are only used only to increase the volume of the piano sample) to bring in the piano instrument; this makes the slow-moving riffs seem more realistic, since a human playing this piece would probably not release each key crisply, but would instead play each note legato. The piano samples (one instrument with six samples to define 7 octaves) are exquisite -- my fingers are getting itchy as my alter-ego contemplates ripping them for my own use (you don't mind, do you, Badlam? ;-))

Ambient strings are introduced early on for a good effect. The beat picks up at pattern 0x4 with a bass piano track and four more piano tracks used for A-minor/A-major atmospheric arpeggios, followed by a snare drum intro at 0x5. Pattern 0x9 repeats the major tonic with the introduction of a brass instrument at 0xC.

The artists change key to B-flat major at 0x14, followed by some fancy footwork (or should I say "fingering"?) at pattern 0x17. Alhough nothing new or cutting edge, the ending had excellent closure and is perfectly timed.

One minor irritation was the right-to-left panning of the hihat sample. Not a big problem, just unexpected for this type of piece. Also, I personally felt the piano trills at 0x14 should have been started one row earlier; the beat sounded just a bit off.

The song's title describes the mood perfectly -- "Don't Cry", i.e., "don't cry for a lost love" or something similar. Although the song is probably not destined for "greatness" (whatever the heck that is) in terms of awards, I know I'll be listening to it often. In my estimation, at least, the artists deserve recognition for this finely-crafted melody which definitely adds to the Scene's treasure-trove of top-notch tracks (God, I love alliteration, don't you? ;-).

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #53

"The Eye of Hope"

File size (uncompressed)

812 Kb

URL:

ftp://ftp.cdrom.com/pub/demos/music/songs/1998/i/i_hope.zip

Date reviewed:

08 Sep 1998
Style:Inspirational Techno
Format:Impulse Tracker (.it)
Time (via ModPlug):3:27
Artist(s):Grimmy of GoTrack ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:6.75 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 7  Middle: 7  Closing: 6  Headphone: 7  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes....and also a tenth!
Review:"Free at last, free at last...thank God Almighty, I'm free at last" Although these stirring words by Martin Luther King Jr. aren't in this song, the sentiment is still there. The opening gave me chills--it's part of a speech given by Rev. King (the "Promised Land" speech). After listening to it, I can begin to understand the power of the man and the depth of emotions he stirred in common folk.

The song's opening is powerful, a percussion track which synchs with a stretch of Rev. King's "Promised Land" speech. This is followed by a soul-stirring series of string chords and kettle drums which evince the "hope" in the title. This song is filled with hope! It brings Dr. King's words to life--"Let Freedom Ring!" I don't know if I'm reacting to the song itself or to Dr. King--probably a little of both--but this piece has moved me deeply and in my opinion deserves a high rating for the excellent mix of chords and percussion with one of Dr. King's most famous speeches.

There was one thing that bothered me slightly: at the ending the final synth sample pans left and right rapidly, which was slightly disconcerting, but only a trivial problem. All in all, this song, like the words of the great man it portrays, is destined for greatness.

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #54

"Betrayal of Mind"

File size (uncompressed)

124 Kb

URL:

ftp://ftp.cdrom.com/pub/demos/music/songs/1998/i/ic-betra.it

Date reviewed:

15 Sep 1998
Style:Symphonic
Format:Impulse Tracker (.it)
Time (via ModPlug):2:32
Artist(s):Coplin of Immortal Coil ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:5.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 5  Middle: 5  Closing: 5  Headphone: 5  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes
Review:The snare and kettledrum samples combined to give this piece a slight military air. I'm not a fan of the type of snare used (sounds like a toy), but it was functional and served its intended purpose well enough. The song possessed strong thematric content although development was a little shy due to the short length. I'm not sure how the title fits in with the "military" milieu proposed by the opening (perhaps it refers to a soldier who is forced to kill against his conscience...?), but IMO, this piece is a solid and interesting melody, well deserving of several plays.
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #55

"Interludisco"

File size (uncompressed)

259 Kb

URL:

http://www.geocities.com/SunsetStrip/Stadium/7744/sounds/interdisc.zip

Date reviewed:

16 Sep 1998
Style:Ambient/Contemplative/Easy Listening
Format:Impulse Tracker (.it)
Time (via ModPlug):2:48
Artist(s):Trib the Brit ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:6.40 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 8  Middle: 8  Closing: 8  Headphone: 8  Technical: 0
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?As sure as the Ravenous Bugblatter Beast of Traal likes to dine on pesky Earthers... ;-) Yes!
Review:The opening is highly reminiscent of Spanish guitar music by Maestro Segovia. Those guitar samples are *awesome* (Trib says, "Thanks to Chris Jarvis for showing me how to use fret noises to make guitars sound more authentic" -- I'd like to thank Chris, too, because his advice helped inspire a -- dare I say it -- masterpiece). The tune is highly melodic, with a strong, recognizable theme from beginning to end.

"Interludisco" is far from your run-of-the mill "disco" music (notice I classified it as "Ambient/Contemplative/Easy Listening"--IMO, at least, it doesn't fit into "disco" as the title implies, even if there is a slight disco backbeat); the opening riffs reach into your chest and grab yer heart (squeezing gently, but persistently). The word I'm searching for here is "poignant", but even this doesn't bring out the full meaning of the piece. "Interludisco" would be perfectly suited as the love theme for a "bandido" picture starring Madonna and Antonio Banderas (perhaps Spielberg is working on the script even as I write this...)

I told you to keep an eye out fer Trib (I've got to put mine back in -- can't see a blasted thing without it!). This guy plays guitar like nobody's business. In my estimation, he's right up there with Ibanez...track on, Trib!

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #56

"Lost on deaf ears"

URL:

ftp://ftp.cdrom.com/pub/demos/music/1998/i/ic-deaf.zip

Date reviewed:

20 Sep 1998
Style:Contemplative
Format:Impulse Tracker (.it)
Time (via ModPlug):2:10
Artist(s):Coplan of Immortal Coil ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:4.50 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 4  Middle: 5  Closing: 5  Headphone: 4  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes
Review:The opening was cool, but it seemed to drag on just a tad bit too long. Very enjoyable middle melody. The theme reminds me of someone thinking about an impending task--something that must be done, but which is unpleasant. The tune seems to encourage the listener to take the hit (i.e., assume the responsibility) and do what needs to be done.

IMO, the opening strings were panned too far to the left, causing a stereo inbalance.

I especially enjoyed the overall volume level which produced a soothing effect, and also the solid percussion track.

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #57

"Enter Dream Man"

File size (uncompressed)

668 Kb

URL:

ftp://ftp.cdrom.com/pub/demos/music/1998/i/ib-swedm.zip

Date reviewed:

20 Sep 1998
Style:Techno/Disco
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):5:32
Artist(s):Strawinski of Interlaced Bytes ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:2.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 2  Middle: 2  Closing: 2  Headphone: 2  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes.
Review:Here's an example of a perfectly good song ruined by a voice sample.

So, okay, you listen to the song for yourself and think, "What the heck is Pete talking about? The only voice sample present is a young woman saying 'It feels so goooooooooooood!' What's wrong with that?" If you don't know, I'm sure nothing I can say will enlighten you, but I'll give it a go anyway.... Think about it: *What* is it that the young woman is moaning so ecstatically about? Only the artist can say for sure what he intended it to mean, yet I think it's not too hard to figure out when taken in conjunction with the title of the song. And if you think this old pirate's just got a dirty mind, well, that may be true, but it doesn't change the truth of what I'm saying here. In my view, songs with racy voice samples containing double entendres have no place in an Internet filled with people of all ages and differing religious and moral backgrounds.

'Nuff said.

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #58

"Herege RMX"

File size (uncompressed)

617 Kb

URL:

ftp://ftp.cdrom.com/pub/demos/music/1998/i/ib-swhrq.zip

Date reviewed:

23 Sep 1998
Style:Trance / Dance
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):4:22
Artist(s):StraWinski of iNTERLACED bytes ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:2.25 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 2  Middle: 3  Closing: 2  Headphone: 2  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes.
Review:A very monotonous tune. I kept hoping for a breather, but the artist kept me in a "trance" (hence my style classification)--after the sixth listen, I couldn't breathe! ;-) There was a most annoying synth instrument which was played too loud at too low a frequency. This overshadowed the main melody, which begins with a nice series of arpeggios at 00:56. The main theme is very catchy (which is why I listened to it as many times as I did), but IMO needed more development.
[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #59

"Almost Done"

URL:

ftp://ftp.cdrom.com/pub/demos/music/1998/i/i-ad.zip

Date reviewed:

24 Sep 1998
Style:Grunge / Hardcore
Format:FastTracker (.xm)
Time (via ModPlug):4:14
Artist(s):isms ([email protected])
Pete's overall rating:1.00 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 1  Middle: 1  Closing: 1  Headphone: 1  
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Not to me, but you might think so.
Review:Aside from the percussion track, I find very little to recommend this piece. Therefore, the less said, the better....No, that's not right--I've got to define *why* the song irritates me so, to help the artist.

To begin with, the constant "wah-wah" effect on one of the primary instruments drove me nuts (it was interesting for the first three listens, but after that the effect began to grate on my nerves). Then there was the lack of a defining theme. I think the title is more appropriate than the artist knows--to me, the song sounds unfinished. As I said, I *did* enjoy some things (the cool percussion track, the fast tempo), but to me at least, the cons outweighed the pros.

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Song #60

"A rocktale"

File size (uncompressed)

165 Kb

URL:

CDROM-1:\MODULES\AUTHORS.A-F\16BEAT\A_ROCKTALE.MOD

Date reviewed:

17 Oct 1998
Style:Rock Fantasy
Format:ProTracker compatible (.mod)
Time (via ModPlug):5:34
Artist(s):16-beat
Pete's overall rating:4.20 (out of 10) [Your mileage may vary]
Rating categories:Intro: 6  Middle: 6  Closing: 3  Headphone: 6  Technical: 0
Worth a 3rd or 4th listen?Yes.
Review:With the demise of Hornet, I am now trying to review songs from "Gryzor's CD-ROM Anthology I" -- of which, this is song 1 of disk 1.

16-beat does a tremendous job here -- as a tracker myself, I respect these "old" 4-channel mods. It took a helluva lot of technical wizardry to coax the old Amigas to produce such sweet music as this!

"Rocktale" starts out as a "rock fantasy" piece with plenty of violins, and morphs into a good solid rock piece

Close was a little loose, though -- there was a bunch of "leftover" patterns.

[Index] [First page] [Prev page] [Next page][Last page]

Send me
email
Back to Pirate Pete's Musical Privateer
This page maintained by Pirate Pete's Software Emporium